• Blog
  • About
  • Contact
  • Archives

in service of the
​common good

I don't believe in the God you don't believe in

17/10/2023

3 Comments

 
​
Shocking attack on Anglican owned hospital in Gaza
“I don’t believe in the God you don’t believe in either”
 
The explosion on Tuesday at the al-Ahli al-Arabi hospital, also known as the Baptist hospital, which killed hundreds of already traumatized civilians must be investigated as a war crime. While Israel claims, as it has in similar circumstance in the past, that Hamas was responsible through a misfunctioning rocket, there is no evidence that this is the case.  It is almost certainly the result of an Israeli strike, intended or not.

I want to respond to this outrage through the words of a weeping Israeli citizen who lost his child in the brutal Hamas attack on a kibbutz “I am sorry, I can no longer believe in God anymore”.
This is the hub of the matter. While this is not in the traditional sense a religious conflict, the facts of the matter are that when an illegal settler is asked by what authority he dares to push Palestinians off their land and resume it for himself, he holds up a Bible and says: “this is the authority”.

There would be no conflict if the illegal assumption of Palestinian land, property and rights was not occurring.

There would be no conflict if Gaza was not permanently and crushingly blockaded.

There would be no conflict if the most right-wing government in Israel’s history was not in provocative and suppressive power.

There would be no conflict if the promise of the Oslo agreement of Palestinian nationhood on 22 percent of original Palestine with East Jerusalem as its capital had been delivered within the promised five-year time frame.

There would be no conflict if the UN sponsored partition of Palestine on a roughly 50/50 percentage basis was enforced in the years following 1945.

There would be no conflict if the conservative/religious right which dominates American politics did not back Israel on the basis that God gave Israel all the land and that Jesus will return when they control it all from the river to the sea.

Hamas’ attack on October 7 was barbaric and must be unconditionally condemned.  But it is simply untrue that it was without provocation.

I weep equally for Jews and Palestinians who have lost the lives of their loved ones. I support entirely the kibbutz citizen who poured out his disbelief. I absolutely do not believe in the God you no longer believe in.

Let us assume for a moment there is God, I fervently believe this to be the case. This God must surely behave consistently and equally, not simply with all humans, but with the whole created order. If any have a particular place, it can only be in service of the order that this God intends for the whole created order. It is simply not credible to believe that one group of people is given divine right to a piece of land that allows them through acts of apartheid, even genocide, to exclude others.

The Bible is reasonably clear about the order that God intends. Justice, mercy, righteousness, humility, hospitality, care of the vulnerable, treating the stranger in your midst as one of your own, are all clearly set out, not simply in the New Testament, but throughout the writings of the Old Testament prophets.   To paraphrase Amos: “I hate I despise your religious practice, but let justice roll down like a river and righteousness like an everlasting stream”. Or Micah: “What does the lord your God require of you, but to do justice love mercy and walk humbly with your God”.

Zionism, Israeli government policy, is a political movement, but it is a political movement that relies on a quasi-religious historical assumption.  Zionism is not the same as Judaism.  The world at large has been immensely blessed by Judaism and by Jewish people. Jewish people have, and do, push well above their weight in many fields of human endeavour, including humanitarian fields.

Zionism and Zionistic propositions do not represent Judaism. I am proud that Judaism lies at the very foundation of Christianity. But I abhor activity in the name of religion which brings pain and suffering through injustice and oppression.
​
Will this article be called antisemitic – of course it will. Should it be? Of course not.   I hope with some humility this article is being written and read in the spirit of the prophets we Christians and Jews share, again paraphrasing “I care nothing for any of your religions, but let justice roll down like waters and righteousness like an everlasting stream”.
 
 
3 Comments
Jacq Wyatte
27/10/2023 12:03:13 am

Well said.

Reply
vidmate.onl link
25/10/2024 11:16:07 am

I wanted to express my gratitude for your insightful and engaging article. Your writing is clear and easy to follow, and I appreciated the way you presented your ideas in a thoughtful and organized manner. Your analysis was both thought-provoking and well-researched, and I enjoyed the real-life examples you used to illustrate your points. Your article has provided me with a fresh perspective on the subject matter and has inspired me to think more deeply about this topic.

Reply
Lillian link
28/3/2025 06:27:05 pm

I deeply appreciate your courageous and prophetic voice in addressing the complexities of the Israeli-Palestinian conflict and the role of religious justifications within it. What I learned from your blog is the crucial distinction between genuine faith, which embodies justice, mercy, and humility, and the dangerous misuse of religious ideology to justify oppression and injustice, and how important it is to differentiate between Judaism as a faith and Zionism as a political movement. I appreciate how you grounded your argument in the teachings of the Old Testament prophets, such as Amos and Micah, reminding us that God's true desire is for justice and righteousness to prevail. What I love most about your blog is your unwavering commitment to speaking truth to power, even when it means facing accusations of antisemitism. Your articulation of the kibbutz citizen's disbelief, your lament for the suffering of both Jews and Palestinians, and your call for justice to 'roll down like waters' are all deeply moving and challenging. Thank you for sharing your perspective and for calling us to a higher standard of moral responsibility. Keep up the vital work!

Reply



Leave a Reply.

    Subscribe


    ​Author

    ​Bishop George Browning. 
    ​Anglican Bishop of Canberra and Goulburn 1993 - 2008.

    ​Inaugural chair Anglican Communion Environment Network

    ​PhD Thesis: Sabbath and the Common Good: An Anglican response to the Environmental Crisis.

    D.Litt. Honoris Causa for contribution to Education

    Centenary Medal 2000 for Service to cmmunity

    ​Patron: Australia Palestine Advocacy Network

    Patron: Palestinian Christians in Australia

    Patron: Sabeel

    ARCHIVE

    Categories

    All

    RSS Feed

    Publications

    Sabbath and the Common Good: Prospects for a New Humanity, Echo Books 2016

    ​Not Helpful: Tales from a truth teller, Echo Books 2021

    Links​

    Barbara May Foundation

    ​Australian Centre for Christianity and Culture

    Australia Palestine Advocacy Network

    ​Christians for an Ethical Society


Proudly powered by Weebly
  • Blog
  • About
  • Contact
  • Archives