• Blog
  • About
  • Contact
  • Archives

in service of the
​common good

accusations of anti-semitism

2/12/2017

6 Comments

 
​Anti-Semitism, one of the oldest forms of racism, is to be thoroughly abhorred, but also to be abhorred is the accusation of anti-Semitism when used in an attempt to silence those who would lift the veil on the cruel subjugation of the Palestinian people by the State of Israel.
 
Once again I am accused of anti-Semitism in the annual report of the Executive Council of Australian Jewry (ECAJ).   They make this accusation on an interpretation of a definition of Anti-Semitism formalised by the International Holocaust Remembrance Alliance (IHRA).
 
Let me reiterate a few facts:
 
·         The notional 22% of historic Palestine that remains for Palestinians is fast disappearing.  The continued expansion of illegal Jewish settlements their connecting roads and infrastructure is denying any real possibility of a Palestinian State, the espoused bi-partisan hope of the Australian Parliament
·         The dehumanizing reality of checkpoints makes daily living for Palestinians close to impossible.
·         Access to water has been almost totally denied the Palestinian population while the Settlements are surrounded by irrigated lawns.
·         Children as young as 12 are incarcerated in military courts, often without charge and without proper legal representation, forced to sign statements in a language they do not understand.
·         The 2 million Palestinians on the Gaza strip live in the most dehumanizing conditions on the planet.
·         One could go on.
 
In Australia:
 
·         A poll of the general population indicates that support for Palestinian rights is increasing as is condemnation of the Israeli occupation.
·         More Australian politicians are whisked off to Israel with all expenses paid than visit any other country in the world.   Why?  Presumably to absorb the Israeli narrative.
·         The ‘Lobby’, call it the Jewish Lobby, the Zionist Lobby, the Israeli Lobby, it does not matter very much, has enormous influence on Australian media and Australian politics. It is very difficult to have published a story which reflects the facts on the ground in the occupied territories without, as John Lyons points out, the source of that story being made to pay a very high price.
·         Why does the ‘Lobby’ have so much influence in Australian domestic affairs?  I have put that question to a number of politicians.  I have suggested it relates to financial donations, but this is denied.  Financial donations are usually the reason why inexplicable attention is given to a particular cause. What other reason could there be?  Clearly the reason cannot be support for a just cause. 
 
Support for Israel is a just cause – but not on any terms. Israel must make clear what it wants. When demands are made of Palestinians, and then met, other demands are made. The demand that the State of Israel be recognised has been met. Now the demand is that Palestinians recognise Israel as a Jewish State.  If that is what it wants then it should immediately withdraw to the 1967 borders and evacuate all the illegal 700,000 settlers on the West Bank.  This is clearly not what Netanyahu or his government intend. Even if this were achieved, which, given numerous statements emanating from members of the Knesset make it extremely unlikely, what then would be the status of the 20% Arab population who currently reside in Israel?
 
If Israel wants a ‘Greater Israel’, a state with borders from the Jordan to the Mediterranean, it cannot under any circumstance be a Jewish State. If Israel wants to be known as a democratic State, then it must grant equal rights to all citizens.  In Israel itself the 20% Arab population endures discriminatory restrictions that do not apply to the Jewish population.   Despite these restrictions, Israel itself cannot be fairly described as an apartheid state.  But this is not the case with the regime it runs in the occupied territories.  Palestinians live under an apartheid regime that appears more uncompromising by the day.
 
My challenge to Australian politicians on both sides of the political divide is do far more than pay lip service to a two-state solution.  Lip service where nothing changes, indeed where the oppression becomes more entrenched year on year, makes Australia compliant to apartheid, a situation long eschewed by Australia in relation to South Africa.
 
The account of an interview by Robert Cohen, a respected but dissident Jewish writer in England’s premier Church of England weekly is apposite to the points I am making https://www.churchtimes.co.uk/articles/2017/1-december/features/features/the-truth-is-simple-but-unwelcome Cohen has been “writing from the edge”, as he puts it, since 2011, primarily about interfaith relations and Israel/Palestine, in a monthly blog, Micah’s Paradigm Shift. The reference is to Micah 6.8: “What does the Lord require of you? To act justly and to love mercy and to walk humbly with your God.”
So far, so uncontroversial. Many of the people whom he criticises implicitly, Christian and Jewish, would endorse that prophetic call. The conclusions that Cohen comes to, however, are sometimes very different from theirs. In particular, he is calling for Churches to commit to “costly solidarity” with the Palestinian people. Among his prescriptions is “refusing to allow your local Jewish communal leadership to set the boundaries of permissible debate on Israel”.
So am I an anti-Semite?
 
·         If demanding that Palestinians have equal rights with Israelis is anti-Semitic then yes I am an anti-Semite.
·         If demanding that Israel end the occupation and allow a free and sustainable Palestinian civil society is anti-Semitic, yes I am an anti-Semite
·         If calling out the Israeli government for its hypocritical values and standards, granting a liberal life style to its own and denying it to the Palestinians is anti-Semitic, then yes I am anti-Semitic.
·         If saying that the policies of the Israeli government toward the Palestinians stand in sharp contrast with the values of righteousness and justice espoused in the Hebrew scriptures, which I honour, is anti-Semitic, then yes I am anti-Semitic.
·         Do I honour Jewish religion?  Absolutely, and with respect probably know far more about it than the average secular Jew.  Do I respect Jewish culture and ethnicity? Absolutely, indeed the Jewish roots within my own family are treasured.
·         Are any Jews members of the Australia Palestine Advocacy Network that I chair?  Absolutely, indeed on its executive. There are a significant number of Australian Jews who make all the points that I make against the Israeli government and yet with greater passion and urgency because, as they claim, the Israeli government does not act in their name.
 
I understand the Hebrew and Christian scriptures to say that any sense of chosenness that might be understood and humbly accepted, is never for oneself, but it is to be acknowledged and implemented in the blessing that must flow to others.  
 
Any attempt to silence me will be treated with the contempt it deserves.  If any disagree with the veracity of the statements I have made then come with me to Palestine and see for yourselves.
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
6 Comments
Bruce Henzell
3/12/2017 03:17:15 am

Absolutely agree. Absolutely necessary and well put. The prophets throughout Israel's history were no less forthright in their condemnation of their government/leadership, and it would be absolutely ludicrous to call them anti-Semitic. In fact it was their sharing in God's love for his people that motivated their calling that leadership to account and to turn around.

Reply
David
3/12/2017 09:12:17 pm

Absolutely agree and as I also honour my own Jewish roots I insist that Israel honour the just pleas from our Palestinian brothers.

Reply
Graham Beattie
3/12/2017 10:31:43 pm

Thoughtful, balanced and helpful post - thanks! Hopefully our politicians will soon come to the point of placing social justice over political self interest. Graham

Reply
Father Dave link
4/12/2017 01:51:40 am

Courageous and passionate, brother (and accurate). Thank you.

We Christians do indeed have a horrible history of anti-Semitism, but when the accusation is levelled at advocates for Palestine like yourself it loses all meaning. This is not only an injustice to those advocating for humanity, but also trivialises the real crimes of the past.

Reply
saul geffen
7/12/2017 05:00:05 am

OK Ill come with you to Israel. But first lets stop in Gaza and publically profess our gay sexuality. Lets also stand in the town square and insult the prophet.
Then if we live lets do the same in Tel Aviv. We could also ask the Egyptians why they blockade Gaza.

Your claims that Israel "must grant equal rights to all of its citizens" are odd when I dont hear you castigate the surrounding regimes in the same way. Or are not the rights of women and homosexuals important?. So you are an anti semite sir. You do not oppose Chinas occupation of Tibet, Turkish occupation of Crete or Australian occupation of indigenous land, or Indonesian occupation of Papua with anything like the vitriol and angst you save for Israel and its Jews. Bishop the Queen, the head of your church, rules Gibraltar in Spain, the Virgin Islands in the Caribbean, the Falklands off Argentina and took and holds them by force. How on earth do you cope with your own hypocrisy?

Would you like to correct this statement "The demand that the State of Israel be recognized has been met." in the light of this from Hamas "https://www.reuters.com/article/us-palestinians-hamas-document/hamas-softens-stance-on-israel-drops-muslim-brotherhood-link-idUSKBN17X1N8"
check the link Bishop.Denies the right of Israel to exist.

You also claim Israel should withdraw from the "occupied territories" Could you let us know who should get the Golan Heights? Isis? Assad? the Kurds? Hezbollah?

You profess christian faith, Id like you to reflect on the true indigenous people of the "occupied territories". This secular Jew remembers a story about a Jew born in Bethlehem (Yep middle of the West Bank) who was circumcised , Bar Mitzvahd and died there. (You might believe he rose and lived again). You'd have to concede then that Jews have been there for quite a long time and have a pretty strong historical claim for ownership.

Oh and Bishop could you tell me how, your claimed superior knowledge of the Jewish faith than the "average secular Jew" means anything other than an insult? How many secular Jews did you ask? What is wrong with being a secular Jew and how does that diminish the strength of my arguments on Israels right to live in secure borders with Jerusalem as its capital.

Your ridiculous religious superstitions and veneration of a deluded messianic Jew from 2000 years ago mean you are less, not more capable of logic.

Reply
Islamic Banking & Finance link
11/12/2017 12:22:13 am

very Informative and useful... Keep it up the great Work..

Reply



Leave a Reply.

    Subscribe


    ​Author

    ​Bishop George Browning. 
    ​Anglican Bishop of Canberra and Goulburn 1993 - 2008.

    ​Inaugural chair Anglican Communion Environment Network

    ​PhD Thesis: Sabbath and the Common Good: An Anglican response to the Environmental Crisis.

    D.Litt. Honoris Causa for contribution to Education

    Centenary Medal 2000 for Service to cmmunity

    ​Patron: Australia Palestine Advocacy Network

    Patron: Palestinian Christians in Australia

    Patron: Sabeel

    ARCHIVE

    Categories

    All

    RSS Feed

    Publications

    Sabbath and the Common Good: Prospects for a New Humanity, Echo Books 2016

    ​Not Helpful: Tales from a truth teller, Echo Books 2021

    Links​

    Barbara May Foundation

    ​Australian Centre for Christianity and Culture

    Australia Palestine Advocacy Network

    ​Christians for an Ethical Society


Proudly powered by Weebly
  • Blog
  • About
  • Contact
  • Archives